## Non-Power-of-2 Gray Counter Design

June 9, 2008So… you want to design a counter with a cycle which is different than a power of 2. You would like to use a Gray counter because of its advantages and just because it is simply beautiful, but alas, your cycle length is not a power of two – what to do?

This post will try to give you a sort of recipe of how to design such a non-power-of-2 Gray counter and the reasoning behind.

First, if your cycle length is an odd number, you are in trouble since this is just not possible to construct a counter with the Gray properties and with an odd cycle length. A simple way to see why it is so, is to notice that a Gray counter changes its parity with each count because only one bit changes at a time.

This naturally means that the parity toggles, but since we have an odd number of states and if we started with even parity – the last state will also have odd parity, and when we wrap around the parity won’t change! Assuming that the first and last states are different, this means that 2 bits must change at a time, thus contradicting the Gray hypothesis.

OK, so we limited ourselves to an even amount of states, is it possible now? It is! We could ask our friend Google and come up with some info and even some patents, but the best discussion on the subject that I found was written by Clive Maxfield here.

When approaching this problem, what (hopefully) should immediately struck us, is that we have to somehow use the reflection property of the Gray code (This method among others is discussed by Clive as well). Let’s take a deeper look at the 4-bit Gray code below.

The pairs of states which have identical distance from the axis of reflection are only different by their MSB. This in turn, means that we could eliminate pairs-at-a-time around the axis of reflection, and arrive to our desired number of states for the counter. Moreover, we notice that the (n-1) LSBs count up to a certain value then change direction and count down again. This property remains true even if we remove any amount of pairs around the axis of reflection.

What we have to do now, is to find this “switching value”, when we reach it on the up-count, toggle the direction bit – **which is also our MSB**, and block the (n-1) LSBs Gray counter for this direction switch cycle (otherwise 2 bits would change). We now count down to the initial state (all zeros). When we reach it, we again have to switch direction and block the counter and so on ad infinitum.

We can use the modular up/down Gray counter I described here, here and here. for our (n-1) LSBs. We have to find a priori the “switching value”, which is the (n-1) bit Gray value of our number of counter states divided by 2. For Example, if you want a 10 state Gray counter then: 10/2 = 5, therefore we need the 5th Gray value of a normal 3 bit Gray code, which turns out to be 110

The rest of the circuit is depicted in the figure below:

It is important to see that we use the minimal possible memory elements required for the Gray counter (i.e. no extra states to remember or pipeline) and that during “direction switching” we gate the clock for the (n-1) LSBs up/down Gray counter using an ordinary clock gate construct.

If we look carefully we see that the “direction switching” logic is basically a mux structure with the select being the direction bit.

A timing diagram of the above circuit for a 10 state Gray counter is also depicted below for clarity.

[…] As you see there are many, many different Gray codes around. Sometimes it is just nice playing around with some combinations. For practical implementations, the only time I personally needed the non standard Gray code was when using a non power of 2 Gray code counter – a topic which was already discussed here. […]

by K-Maps Walks and Gray Codes « Adventures in ASIC Digital Design September 26, 2008 at 4:53 pmI really love it…. Thanks…

-Srinivasa S S

by Srinivasa S S February 5, 2010 at 12:47 pm