## Real World Examples #1 – The DBI bug

January 3, 2008OK, back after the long holidays (which were spent mainly in bed due to severe sickness, both of myself and my kids…) with some new ideas.

I thought it would be interesting to pick up some real life examples and blog about them. I mainly concentrated so far on design guide lines, tricky puzzles and general advice. I guess it would benefit many if we dive into the real world a bit. So – I added a new category called (in a very sophisticated way) “real life examples”, which all this stuff will be tagged under.

Let’s start with the first one.

The circuit under scrutiny, was supposed to calculate a DBI (Data Bus Inversion) bit for an 8-bit vector. Basically, on this specific application, if the 8-bit vector had more than 4 “1”s a DBI bit should have gone high, otherwise it should have stayed low.

The RTL designer decided to add all the bits up and if the result was 4 or higher the DBI bit was asserted – this is not a bad approach in itself and usually superior to LUT.

The pseudo code looked something like that:

assign sum_of_ones = data[0] + data[1] + data[2] + data[3] + data[4] + data[5] + data[6] + data[7];

assign dbi_bit = (sum_of_ones > 3);

The problem was that accidentally the designer chose “sum_of_ones” to be **3-bit wide only!** This meant that if the vector was all “1”s, the adder logic that generates the value for sums_of_ones would wrap around and give a value of “000”, which in turn would not result in the DBI bit being asserted as it should. During verification and simulation the problem was not detected for some reason (a thing in itself to question), but we were now facing with a problem we needed to fix as cheaply as possible. We decided to try a metal fix.

The $50K (or whatever the specific mask set cost was) question is how do you fix this as fast as possible with as little overhead as possible, assuming you have only 4 input NAND and 4 input NOR gates available?

Answer in the next post

## Leave a Reply