h1

Late Arriving Signals

May 23, 2007

As I mentioned before, it is my personal opinion that many digital designers put themselves more and more further away from the physical implementation of digital circuits and concentrate more on the HDL implementations. A relatively simple construction like the one I am about to discuss, is already quite hard to debug directly in HDL. With a visual aid of how the circuit looks like, it is much easier (and faster) to find a solution.

The classic example we will discuss is that of a late arriving signal. Look at the picture below. The critical path through the circuit is along the red arrow. Let’s assume that there is a setup violation on FF6.
late_arriving_signal_1.png Let’s also assume that in this example the logic cloud marked as “A”, which in turn controls the MUX that chooses between FF3 and FF4, is quite heavy. The combination of cloud “A” and cloud “B” plus the MUXes in sequence is just too much. But we have to use the result of “A” before calculating “B”! What can be done?

The most important observation is that we could duplicate the entire logic that follows “A”. We assume for the duplicated blocks that one time the result of “A” was a logic “0” and in another logic “1”. Later we could choose between the two calculations. Another picture will make it clearer. late_arriving_signal_2.png
Notice how the MUX that selected between FF3 and FF4 has vanished. There is now a MUX that selects between FF3 and FF5 (“A” result was a “0”) and a MUX in the parallel logic that selects between FF4 and FF5 (“A” result was a “1”) .
At the end of the path we introduced a new MUX which selects between the two calculations we made, this time depending on cloud “A”. It is easy to see that although this implementation takes more area due to the duplicated logic, the calculation of the big logic clouds “A” and “B” is done in parallel rather than in series.

This technique is relatively easy to implement and to spot if you have a circuit diagram of your design. Also do not count on the synthesis tool to do this for you. It might be able to do it with relatively small structures but when those logic clouds get bigger, you should implement this trick on your own – you will see improvements in timing (and often in synthesis run time). What you pay for is area and maybe power – nothing comes for free…

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: